Addressing organizational change in a hospital department
About this project
We worked with 140+ health professionals in a hospital department. Our original goal was to understand how different professions in the department worked together. However, after the hospital changed the way that the department was structured and the work culture became negative, we adjusted the research question to focus of the impact of these changes on staff.
Employer
University of Toronto
My Role
Ethnographer
Team
Team of 2: ethnographer, team lead
What is an ethnographer?
An ethnographer is someone who does research using ethnography. Ethnography is a research method from anthropology that involves spending time observing people in their own environments. The ethnographer can choose to participate in the activities going around them (participant-observation) or can simply observe. Either way, the goal is to gain a deep understanding of what people do, why they do it, and how they see the world around them.
We asked
- How does interprofessional collaboration work in this environment?
- What is the impact of this major organizational change on interprofessional collaboration?
- How might we address the negative culture change in the department?
We answered with
230 + hours of ethnography
independently done by me
27 in-depth interviews
12 done by me
2 co-creation workshops
developed & facilitated by me
Making sense of the data
We used qualitative data analysis software (MAXQDA) to analyze our interview data for common themes. We started out with lots of different themes, but refined them as we continued with analysis.
In our co-creation workshops, we use design thinking methods to make sense of our data. More specifically, these included braindumping and brainwriting to ideate solutions to the culture changes that the staff were facing. We also used affinity diagrams to cluster ideas with a common theme.
Our findings
From our interview and ethnographic data, we learned that people were very unhappy with the organizational change. More specifically, they:
- felt that they had lost their relationships with their team members
- had increased workloads and stress levels
- felt unsure about the future of the department
- felt distrustful of management
Staff turnover increased.
Our co-creation workshops and observations told us that staff wanted:
- an opportunity to mourn the way that things used to be
- more communication with management and with each other
- greater clarification of their roles, especially when they were similar to others in the department
- a clear way for management to measure the impact of the organizational changes on patient care
Sharing our findings
We shared these finding with the department through a presentation. We wanted to update them on what we were doing and give them a chance to ask questions. Our goal here was to build rapport through transparency.
The staff involved in the workshops also shared findings through word-of-mouth.
Impact & Outcomes
Stress-relief for staff
Facilitating open conversations in co-creation workshop
Reshaping culture
Empowering staff to make desired changes by guiding them through ideation
Challenges & lessons
Distrust
This was the first time I worked on a research project where people did not really trust the project (or me) and the negative culture change in the department made this worse. I learned to build rapport by recognizing and addressing people’s concerns about my work through things like informal Q&A sessions or handing out information brochures about the project to people who seemed reluctant to approach me.
Workplace stress
Increased stress from the organizational & culture change made people less willing to participate in the research. I learned to address the stress they were dealing with and build rapport by doing informal wellness checks and rotating between participants to reduce how much time I was asking them for.